Complaints Concerning the Journal
Policy Statement
PJN is committed to receiving and addressing complaints in a fair, respectful, timely, confidential, and impartial manner. Authors, reviewers, readers, editorial personnel, institutions, and other stakeholders may raise concerns about the Journal's policies, procedures, services, editorial conduct, peer-review process, publication practices, or the conduct of individuals acting on behalf of PJN.
Complaints may concern delays or lack of communication; alleged discourtesy, discrimination, or inappropriate conduct; breaches of confidentiality; conflicts of interest; alleged bias or interference in editorial decisions; peer-review irregularities; errors in publication; suspected research or publication misconduct; data protection or privacy concerns; and non-compliance with published Journal policies.
All complaints shall be submitted through the Official PJN Complaint Form. A complaint concerning the Editor-in-Chief, or one in which the Editor-in-Chief has an actual or perceived conflict of interest, shall be directed to the PNA-designated publisher representative or another independent person or body designated by PNA. A complaint concerning the publisher or a PNA representative shall be referred to an appropriate independent PNA authority, without compromising editorial independence over individual manuscript decisions.
A complaint should identify the issue, relevant manuscript or publication where applicable, persons or processes involved, dates, and supporting information. PJN may consider anonymous complaints when they contain sufficiently specific and verifiable information, although lack of contact details may limit the Journal's ability to seek clarification or communicate an outcome.
The person handling a complaint shall acknowledge receipt within a reasonable period, ordinarily within ten working days, and assess whether the matter falls within the Journal's remit. The Journal may request further information, review relevant editorial records, consult an unconflicted editor or independent expert, or refer matters involving research integrity to the relevant institution or responsible authority.
Complaints shall be handled by individuals who are not directly implicated and who have no relevant conflict of interest. Where necessary, the Editor-in-Chief or designated authority shall appoint an independent reviewer or refer the matter to PNA. The Journal shall distinguish complaints about administrative service or conduct from appeals against editorial decisions, which are handled under the separate Appeals policy.
PJN shall communicate the outcome to the complainant when appropriate and legally permissible. The Journal may explain that confidentiality prevents disclosure of certain details. Records of complaints, investigations, findings, actions, and communications shall be maintained securely and access limited to persons with a legitimate role.
No person shall be subjected to retaliation for raising a complaint in good faith. Deliberately false, malicious, threatening, or abusive communications may be addressed appropriately, but disagreement with an editorial decision or criticism of the Journal shall not, by itself, be treated as misconduct.
Access the Official PJN Complaints Form.
1. Scope and Applicability
This policy applies to complaints about PJN, its editorial and publication processes, and the conduct of its editors, reviewers, staff, and representatives. It does not replace institutional procedures for employment matters, professional regulation, research misconduct investigations, or legal complaints, although PJN may refer matters to the appropriate institution or authority.
2. Definitions
Complaint: A concern or expression of dissatisfaction about the Journal, its procedures, services, policies, publication practices, or the conduct of persons acting for the Journal.
Complainant: An individual or organization submitting a complaint.
Conflict of interest: A relationship, interest, or circumstance that could reasonably impair, or be perceived to impair, impartial handling of a complaint.
Independent handling: Review by a person who is not implicated in the complaint and has no relevant conflict of interest.
Retaliation: An adverse action taken against a person because that person raised or assisted with a complaint in good faith.


