Withdrawal of Manuscripts and Published Articles

Policy Statement

PJN recognizes that a manuscript may need to be withdrawn before publication in limited circumstances. Withdrawal shall be handled transparently, documented in the editorial record, and distinguished from rejection, removal of a duplicate submission, correction, retraction, or removal of an already published article.

Before a final editorial decision, the corresponding author may request withdrawal by submitting a written request to the Editorial Office through OJS or the Journal's official contact channel. The request must identify the manuscript and state the reason. Where there are multiple authors, PJN may require confirmation that all authors agree, particularly where an authorship dispute or disagreement is apparent.

PJN may consider withdrawal after acceptance but before publication only for exceptional and adequately documented reasons, such as a serious ethical concern, material error that cannot be resolved through revision, legal concern, or a substantiated authorship or consent issue. The Editor-in-Chief shall assess the request and may seek clarification, supporting documentation, or institutional input.

A manuscript shall not be withdrawn merely to avoid an unfavorable editorial decision, facilitate simultaneous submission elsewhere, or conceal suspected misconduct. Where a manuscript is under active investigation for plagiarism, duplicate submission, data fabrication, falsification, or another serious concern, PJN may suspend processing while the concern is assessed.

Once an article has been formally published as part of the scholarly record, it shall not be treated as an ordinary unpublished manuscript withdrawal. If a significant problem is identified, PJN shall consider an appropriate editorial action, which may include a correction, expression of concern, retraction, or, only where legally or ethically necessary, removal of content. The Journal shall follow its Corrections, Retractions and Version Control policy and applicable COPE guidance.

PJN shall not silently delete a published article or alter its scholarly record without an explanatory notice, except where limited removal of specific information is legally required or necessary to protect an individual from serious harm. Where content must be removed, the Journal shall preserve a bibliographic record and provide an explanatory statement to the extent legally permissible.

The Journal shall retain an internal record of withdrawal requests and decisions, including the date, reason, parties consulted, decision-maker, and any notice or OJS record created. Personal or confidential information shall be handled in accordance with applicable privacy and data-protection requirements.

1. Scope and Applicability

This policy applies to all manuscript submissions from initial receipt until publication, and to published articles when a request or concern may require correction, retraction, expression of concern, or removal. It applies to authors, the Editor-in-Chief, handling editors, the Editorial Office, and the publisher.

2. Definitions

Withdrawal: The discontinuation of editorial consideration of an unpublished manuscript before it becomes part of the published scholarly record.

Pre-publication withdrawal: Withdrawal of a submission or accepted manuscript before formal publication.

Retraction: A formal notice that a published article is unreliable or should not be relied upon, in whole or in part.

Expression of concern: A formal editorial notice alerting readers to a significant unresolved concern about a published article.

Removal: The exceptional action of taking full text or specific content offline, ordinarily for legal, privacy, or serious safety reasons, while preserving an appropriate bibliographic record where possible.