Appeals of Editorial Decisions
Policy Statement
PJN provides a mechanism for authors to appeal an editorial decision when they believe that the decision resulted from a significant factual error, a material procedural irregularity, an undisclosed conflict of interest, demonstrable bias, or a serious misunderstanding of the submitted work. An appeal is a request for reconsideration on specified grounds and is not an automatic second round of peer review.
An appeal shall be submitted in writing by the corresponding author to the Editor-in-Chief within thirty calendar days from the date the decision was communicated, unless exceptional circumstances justify a later submission. The appeal must identify the manuscript and decision, state the specific grounds, respond to the material reasons for the decision, and provide relevant supporting evidence. Where appropriate, the corresponding author shall confirm that co-authors are aware of and support the appeal.
Disagreement with the academic judgment of the editor or reviewers, without evidence of a significant error or procedural concern, is ordinarily insufficient grounds for appeal. An appeal shall not be used to introduce an entirely new manuscript, add new data that materially changes the submission, or pressure the Journal to reverse a decision solely because the authors disagree with the outcome.
The Editor-in-Chief shall conduct an initial assessment of whether the appeal presents grounds warranting reconsideration. If the Editor-in-Chief made or materially participated in the original decision, or has another relevant conflict of interest, the appeal shall be assigned to an unconflicted senior editor or an independent person designated by the Editorial Board or PNA, as appropriate.
Where an appeal is accepted for consideration, PJN may seek advice from an editor not involved in the original decision, obtain an independent expert assessment, request clarification from reviewers, or review the editorial record. The Journal may uphold the original decision, modify it, invite further revision, or arrange additional peer review. The appeal review shall not guarantee acceptance or publication.
PJN aims to acknowledge an appeal within ten working days and communicate an outcome ordinarily within thirty to sixty calendar days, depending on complexity and the availability of independent advice. If additional time is required, the Journal shall inform the corresponding author of the delay and provide an updated estimate.
The outcome of the appeal shall be communicated in writing and shall ordinarily be final within the Journal's editorial process. A subsequent complaint alleging procedural misconduct, discrimination, conflict of interest, or failure to follow this policy may be submitted under the Complaints policy. Such a complaint is distinct from a further appeal on the merits of the editorial decision.
All appeal records, including the appeal submission, supporting documents, persons consulted, decision, and communications, shall be retained in the editorial record and handled confidentially.
1. Scope and Applicability
This policy applies to authors who seek reconsideration of an editorial decision on a manuscript submitted to PJN, and to the Editor-in-Chief, handling editors, Editorial Board members, reviewers, and other persons involved in the appeal process. It applies to decisions made at initial screening, peer review, revision, and post-review stages, where an appeal is permitted.
2. Definitions
Appeal: A formal written request for reconsideration of an editorial decision on specified factual, procedural, or ethical grounds.
Appellant: The corresponding author or an authorized representative submitting an appeal on behalf of the authors.
Procedural irregularity: A material departure from the Journal's stated editorial procedures that may have affected the fairness or validity of the decision.
Independent reviewer: An editor or expert who was not involved in the original decision and has no relevant conflict of interest.
Final editorial decision: The decision reached by the authorized editor after considering the manuscript, peer-review reports, author responses, and applicable Journal policies.


